Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch



Welcome to
Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch Blog. Our objective is to promote the institutions of democracy,social justice,Human Rights,Peace, Freedom of Expression, and Respect to humanity in Rwanda,Uganda,DR Congo, Burundi,Sudan, Tanzania, Kenya,Ethiopia, and Somalia. We strongly believe that Africa will develop if only our presidents stop being rulers of men and become leaders of citizens. We support Breaking the Silence Campaign for DR Congo since we believe the democracy in Rwanda means peace in DRC. Follow this link to learn more about the origin of the war in both Rwanda and DR Congo:http://www.rwandadocumentsproject.net/gsdl/cgi-bin/library


Friday, August 6, 2010

On the BBC's Africa Have Your Say, on Rwanda

By Ann Garrison (about the author


On July 14th, amidst escalating election violence and repression, Democratic Green Party of Rwanda Vice President Andre Kagwa Kwisereka was found beheaded, with a machete left nearby, in the wetlands of the Makula River in Rwanda's Butare Province, in a grisly murder reminiscent of the Rwanda Genocide, in which upwards of a million people were killed, many with machetes and crude farm implements. Just over a week later, the BBC's Africa Have Your Say produced a program asking the curious question, "Can Rwanda have a free and fair election?"

Have Your Say put many voices on the air, some of them quite critical, regarding Rwanda's upcoming August 9th presidential polls, but it was very late, after an election year racked by violence, arrests, assassinations, and torture, all suffered by critics of Rwandan President Paul Kagame, for the BBC to be asking "Can Rwanda have a free and fair election?"

It's been obvious to anyone paying attention that there would be no free and fair election in Rwanda, because all the viable opposition parties were prevented from registering, and were routinely interrogated and harassed. Many were eventually arrested, many are still in prison, or disappeared, and many of those arrested have reported torture. Independent journalists have fled across the Rwandan border to Uganda, or been assassinated or arrested themselves.

On July 13th, the Vice President of the Democratic Green Party of Rwanda was finally found beheaded by machete.

On July 21st, six more members of Bernard Ntaganda's P.S. Imberakuri Party were arrested.



The world has been so radically changed by the Internet that such things are known all over the world almost as soon as they happen. I received news that Kwisereka's body had been found within hours and received three notifications, with names of those arrested, from credible sources including the Rusesabagina/Hotel Rwanda Foundation and a European branch of P.S. Imberakuri, on the same day they were arrested.

Despite all this and more, the BBC seriously entertained the Kagame government's Kafkaesque argument that opposition parties had not been able to register because they did not check the boxes and follow all the proper procedures to register.

If a government, which determines proper procedures, keeps saying the opposition didn't follow proper procedures, no matter how hard they tried, no matter how many meetings they attended, no matter how much paper they submitted, no matter how many bureaucratic mazes they tried to find their way through, then obviously, they didn't follow proper procedures. Not according to the government, in this case the Rwandan government, which determines who has properly proceeded. (Rwanda has courts, but not an independent judiciary to rule on election law or anything else.)

I followed all the news and firsthand reports, from the opposition leaders, daily, for months, as the Democratic Green Party of Rwanda made endless applications amd supplications and sought meeting after meeting with various Rwandan officials, and tried over and over again to convene. Was I there myself? No, I was not; nor was anyone in Rwanda wandering through Rwanda's bureaucratic maze, day after day, with Democratic Green Party of Rwanda President Frank Habineza and other Rwanda Greens. And in almost a year's time, the NY Times East/Central Africa correspondent Nicholas Kristoff made not a single visit or call to any of the opposition candidates struggling to contest the election.

I was on the phone to Frank Habineza several times a week, at first, then to both FDU-Inkingi Party's Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza and P.S.-Imberakuri Party's Bernard Ntaganda. And I read all the English language papers.

I also read papers they submitted, read the government's responses, and watched from a distance as the Democratic Green Party of Rwanda saw them blocked again and again.

In October 2009, the BBC did a very good job of covering one of the Rwanda Greens' attempts to convene in Kigali, which was broken up by violence, producing the podcast available here: http://goo.gl/r33W, in which an injured delegate reported that a man had stood up behind her and begun chanting "Hail the RPF!" (Rwanda's ruling Rwandan Patriotic Front party), then hit her in the back with a chair. They also put Green Party Chair Frank Habineza on the air saying, "There is no rule of law in Rwanda! . . . If you want to keep us out of the elections, and you want to get 99% of the vote, then you have to say it!"

After the BBC report about that meeting, the Greens met with officials about whether or not they would be allowed to hold a meeting, which concluded in dates for further meetings about whether or not they could have another meeting about whether or not they could hold another meeting after that to talk about the possibility of perhaps having another meeting to talk, once again, about the possibility of having a meeting about whether or not they might be allowed to convene.

Various district mayors pulled their permits for a DGPR convention, a required "procedure" for registering a political party in Rwanda, amidst this endless runaround as well.

The government told the Rwanda Greens that they had to arrange police protection, to assure safety, then the Rwandan Police told them that they weren't in the business of assuring safety at political conventions.

Did the BBC review its own invaluable reporting, including their radio report on the Rwanda Greens' failed meeting in November, and their text reports on journalist Jean Leonard Rugambage's assassination by gunfire and Rwanda Green Party Vice President André Kwisereka's beheading by machete, and much more election violence? If so, didn't they realize how very late it was to be asking "Can Rwanda have a free and fair election?" 

There are certainly advantages to reporting "on the ground" in Rwanda, especially in the Rwandan countryside where the majority of Rwanda's population, impoverished and malnourished rural subsistence farmers who speak only Kinyarwanda, struggle to survive, but no one had to be "on the ground" to see how ridiculous all this was. All they had to do was pay attention, and the Rwandan government counted on most of the world turning away, as they are so famously reported to have turned away from Rwanda in 1994.

A more relevant BBC Africa Have Your Say would be: "How should the international community react to the Rwandan election after it's staged on August 9th? Should they recognize its validity?"

A group of Rwandan exiles, Congolese activists, and scholars will be holding a conference at the National Press Club in Washington D.C. on August 3rd to, for one, call on the U.S. not to recognize the validity of the election.

Another pertinent forum would be: "What is the reality of Rwanda's vaunted 'economic miracle'"?

Consider this study published on the website of the Rusesabagina Hotel Rwanda Foundation: "Rwanda Today: When Foreign Aid Hurts More Than It Helps."

Consider this passage from "False Reconciliation," an essay by Canadian academic Susan Thomson, who has done field work in Rwanda, though she reports, in an unfinished chapter of a book, that authorities picked her up and deposited her in a re-education camp, after telling her to stop talking to a lot of lying Rwandan peasants, who are the majority of Rwandans.

But most foreign visitors do not see the deep poverty and daily hardships that confront ordinary Rwandans. For most of them, Hutu and Tutsi alike, life since the genocide is not as bright and shiny as the authorities in Kigali would pretend.

Some 90 per cent of Rwandans are peasants who rely on subsistence agriculture. Few of them have benefited from the country's rapid reconstruction. The gap between the wealthy urbanites and the poor rural dwellers is on the increase. Government policies favour the urban elite, many of whom are Tutsi who returned to the country after the genocide. --A False Reconciliation, http://goo.gl/MrFX

These questions, are most relevant in the US and UK, which are the dominant foreign powers in East/Central region, and the most generous foreign donors to Rwanda. The US has donated over $1 billion, $34 million in United States taxpayer-funded foreign assistance to Rwanda since 2000, and President Obama proposes another $240,200,000 fiscal
year 2011 budget.

Many, including Professor Susan Thomson and I, and Rwanda's newspaper editors who have fled to Uganda, expect extremes of violence on election day as rural Rwandans are forced to the polls, though press may not venture, or, may not be allowed to venture close enough to observe this.

Though many Rwandan exiles and supporters of democracy in Rwanda think that the U.S. and Commonwealth election observers should not go, Susan Thomson has said that she believes the election observers should go to protect Rwanda's majority rural peasant population from further election violence.

Defense Minister Gen. James Kabarebe (R) speaks to US AFRICOM chief General William Ward, on a recent visit in Rwanda.

Can Rwanda have a free and fair election given US military influence in the region?


The BBC will never produce that Have Your Say, but that might be the real question that needs asking.

I don't believe we know the cost of U.S. military "assistance" to Kagame's Rwandan Defense Force, because the Pentagon often doesn't commonly share those numbers, but U.S. citizens should consider our military's operations and influence in Rwanda, as reported in the Rwanda News Agency (RNA), with the comic headline: "US military not intending to control Africa - says military chief":

"Kigali: A new US military program training African armies including Rwanda is not a US move to dominate the African continent, a senior Rwanda military chief said Monday.

"We are not blind. We know what we want," said RDF Chief of Staff for Land Forces, Lt. Gen. Caesar Kayizari, at a press briefing on the sidelines of a continental conference on the Africa Endeavor 2010 program.

Close to 150 participants from 33 African nations - from East Africa and the ECOWAS sub-regions are meeting in Kigali for a four-day conference preparing for a joint military exercise dubbed Africa Endeavour (AE) 2010, scheduled for August in Accra, Ghana."

Here's another RNA report, about a U.S. defense contractor, Northrop Grumman with a renewed contract to train Rwandan soldiers: "US firm wins contract to continue training Rwandan soldiers":

"Kigali: Defense firm Northrop Grumman Corporation on Tuesday won the extension of its contract to continue training Rwandan soldiers, the U.S. Department of State announced.

Under the deal, Northrop Grumman Corporation continues providing staff to conduct peacekeeping operations and humanitarianism assistance training for Rwanda and other countries as part of the African Contingency Operations Training and Assistance (ACOTA) program."

American should consider the consequence of AFRICOM, the U.S. Africa Command, in Rwanda, arming, "advising," organizing, dispatching, and otherwise exercising huge influence over that country's army, the Rwandan Defense Force, which Umuseso Editor Charles Kabonero calls "its most influential institution. " President Paul Kagame, when he was the head of the Rwandan Defense Force, trained at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, where future generals learn to plan invasions, and his son Ivan Kagame is now a student at West Point.
Next Page




Next Page

26 comments:

Anonymous said...

Particulаrlу pоpular ԁuring the 1950s and 1960s ωere costume
partiеs or themed cocktail partiеs. She dіdn't look like a pro in her movements, but she was relaxed and more confident. "The smoke was so thick that no one could hear a word.

my website - Flapper dress

Anonymous said...

Once she had the class put on a play, and she chose me to be the one to place the needle from the record player at a specific place in
the MIDDLE of a song. For something really entertaining, you
can be a ghost of a different color, and choose a sheet that is black, green, blue,
red or purple. Anne Keipper said Thursday that she was surprised to learn of the lawsuit because she had
heard nothing about the matter since the day it occurred,
Feb.

my webpage - red shoes

Anonymous said...

Back in 1992 both hydroxide antacids and the iron supplement
ferrous sulfate were reported to interfere.

It is handy for keeping your computer safe, but it takes up a fair bit
of processing power to run it regularly. Her most recent side boob exposure
brings up some interesting observations.

Also visit my web blog - big deal

Anonymous said...

If he starts eye balling other women in front of you it's over. Once the aspiring student is equipped with the basic knowledge and tools, he or she can opt to enroll in forex courses dealing with more advanced materials. You can still save your home and an attorney can help you find the best and most timely way to do so.

Feel free to visit my page Done deal

Anonymous said...

Tгеat yοurself (and your dοllагs) to the best you сan afford.

Some Coach faсtoгy stοres will marκ down their prе-ԁiscounted bags, and maу аlso offеr in-store
coupоns. Tгavelling back from a workshop in Ireland
a couple οf years bаck, I sat myself dоwn at а comfortable window seat on the midday Dublin
to Gеneѵa flight.

Stop by my homeρage - cheap handbag

Anonymous said...

I don't really plan ahead of time unless I'm making an item for a specific occasion or
a custom order, so I usually just take a trip to the bead store or browse online and I buy whatever
seems to catch my attention at the time and that drives my creations.

Fresh flowers look pretty and elegant in the hair and contribute a lovely perfume.
"These ladies are only a few of the highly visible and well deserving Barbettes we seek to feature in the coming 2010 episodes.

Here is my web page; hair Accessories

Anonymous said...

Also called "mirror" handbags, the replica handbags usually have a FULL money back
policy that assures quality while purchasing or money back.

There were instances when I didn't actually know I had to consider something. It will fit your physique completely if you would like this to look great you.

My blog post cheap handbags

Anonymous said...

I first became an MBT convert about 10 years ago when they were
still quite a new idea were I live. Just because you have arthritis, the simplest thing does not have to be difficult.
This gives the video a cinematic quality (it's great for wedding video among other things).

Also visit my weblog ... shoe carnival

Anonymous said...

We are very mindfulchristian louboutinshoes are really loved by women,
and many turn out fascinated from the signature red outsoles.
“Nine o’clock” her sunny little clock blinked at her.
Don't worry if you can't find any Red shoes,
you can always paint an old pair of shoes red using spray paint.

Anonymous said...

Get Lisa's FREE newsletter with dating advice and tips at. Best scene to me was Betty White and Sandra Bullock's impromptu "dances" in the woods.
I strongly suggest you read Chapter 9 in my e-book,.

Look at my weblog - big deal

Anonymous said...

Imagine all the changes happening in the 20′s: WWI ended; women’s careers grew outside the usual homemaker role; and
Europe’s jazz was introduced in the U. If you are looking for a great costume
idea, you should consider wearing a flapper dress costume.

It would be great to see Berenice elevate her red carpet style this awards season by
choosing her hairstyle and accessories more carefully.

Anonymous said...

The reason why this is so is because it has a side vent skirt made out of very good workmanship.

Overlap the elastic a couple of inches and sew
it in place. The doll typically wears a rather ornate and feminine dress,
containing some combination of feathers,.

Also visit my blog :: harem pants

Anonymous said...

Сasсаԁes of silk anԁ satin, with silvеr and gоld acсents are the epitome of glamοur аnd elegance thіs spring.

Women wеre ԁrοpping fгom еxhaustion as theу expеcted
to have spotless houses and enteгtain, plus hоld a job.
We сan make anу color foг you accorԁing to yоur requires.


Here is mу pagе - http://elestiloimporta.blogspot.de/2013/01/abrigo-rojo.html

Anonymous said...

Shе killeԁ the two bad witсhes in Oz; ѕhe
helped the Scareсrοw, the Tin Man, аnd the
Cowаrdlу Liοn to go to the Emeгаld Citу to find the
Wizarԁ аnd get ωhаt they ωant.
Now, flогal is probably my lеast favorite of all thе tгends.
Thе phοtos weгe obѵiοuѕly snapped by
the gimlet-eyed paрarazzi.

Also viѕit my weblοg - red shoes

Anonymous said...

I get cheаpеr DVDs on sаle οr іf I just ωаіt a cοuple monthѕ for them to becоme older.
This iѕ pаrtісulaгlу true during busy tіmes of thе yеar.

Τhere aгe manу great геaѕons to ωatch for repossеssed сars for salе.


My weblog - wiki.oziosi.org

Anonymous said...

Initіally ρеrсеіved aѕ a rеligiouѕ matter,
it turns out to be a jealousy gay crimе. The Austrian jeωeler Ρeter
Aloisson has launched a uniquе and innοvаtivе і - Phοne 3G Kіngs Button aѕ the world's most expensive mobile phone. Conclusion: GM had the perfect car for a kid's wаllpapеr.


My websіte - cheap cars

Anonymous said...

Treаt уourself (and youг dollarѕ) tо the best you can affoгd.
Thе іnteгiors of the bags aгe аs stunning as thе exteгіor, аnԁ the bags are quіte roomy, ωhich allows for lotѕ of ѕрaсe to aсcommоdate
all yοur eѕsеntialѕ. It's past too far to begin as soon as the surprise is on the way, now is the time to prepare.

Take a look at my web page: cheap handbags

Anonymous said...

Dіgging results in disorgаnization that will requirе continual refοlding
and aggravаtion. DEЅIGN STΥLEЅ
Feng Shui (pronounced fung shway) has become quite trendy in dеsign and functionalіty in part beсause of the currеnt еmphasis on
glοbal environmеnt. It’s a сrystallіne roсk
which is alsο known as shining stone.

Lоok into my blοg ... home interiors

Anonymous said...

The bοrrower as the seller of the prоpегty
does not havе any finаnсial gain in the short-sale but benefits only in terms of avoіding
forеclosurе ρroceedіngѕ.
As уouг hοme stuԁiο groωs, the value of
yοuг еquipment is gοіng tο grоw aѕ ωell.
It is liκe а small park bеcause you can see treeѕ in ciгcular planters and beside it there
arе benсhes that offer seаts
to ωindow shoppеrѕ anԁ сuѕtomeгs.


Hеrе is my blog; http://schapedia.com

Anonymous said...

Let me know how your wedding goeѕ'and how well your stationery worked out. It does give you unrestricted admittance to the Grand Canyon West, whereby you can use the free shuttle bus to see Guano Point, Eagle Point, the Hualapai Ranch, and the Native American Village. If you keep this in mind and think about your budget, you can easily spend your Las Vegas vacation doing budget friendly activities that will save you big bucks.

My web page; souvenir

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to tell my little brother, that he should also pay a quick visit this weblog on regular basis to get updated from newest reports.

My site :: microsoft exchange

Anonymous said...

Wonderful article! This is the type of info that are meant to be shared around the web.
Shame on Google for now not positioning this post higher!
Come on over and visit my web site . Thank you =)

My homepage: trade in value of a car

Anonymous said...

Hello, i thіnκ thаt i notісеԁ
уοu vіsiteԁ my wеb sitе thuѕ
і got herе to go bаcκ thе want?
.ӏ'm attempting to in finding issues to enhance my website!I guess its good enough to make use of a few of your concepts!!

My weblog: Cash for cars Surrey

oakleyses said...

gucci handbags, polo ralph lauren, air max pas cher, nike shoes, prada handbags, burberry outlet online, coach outlet, louis vuitton outlet, tory burch outlet, louboutin shoes, nike free, nike air max, nike air max, polo ralph lauren outlet, ray ban outlet, longchamp handbags, louis vuitton handbags, true religion outlet, red bottom shoes, louis vuitton outlet, prada outlet, longchamp outlet online, longchamp outlet, coach purses, michael kors outlet online, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton outlet online, coach outlet, michael kors outlet online, true religion, jordan shoes, nike air max, louis vuitton, coach outlet store online, kate spade outlet online, michael kors outlet online, christian louboutin outlet, tiffany and co jewelry, chanel handbags, burberry outlet online, true religion outlet, tiffany jewelry, kate spade handbags, michael kors outlet online, michael kors outlet store, christian louboutin shoes

oakleyses said...

air jordan, louis vuitton pas cher, ralph lauren pas cher, ralph lauren, longchamp, north face, sac louis vuitton, north face pas cher, mulberry, nike roshe, longchamp, roshe run, vans pas cher, lululemon, michael kors uk, burberry pas cher, timberland, mac cosmetics, louis vuitton, nike air force, hollister, oakley pas cher, guess pas cher, hollister, longchamp pas cher, hollister, nike free pas cher, chaussure louboutin, nike free, air max, nike trainers, lacoste pas cher, sac michael kors, hermes pas cher, nike blazer pas cher, louis vuitton uk, scarpe hogan, new balance pas cher, nike roshe run, tn pas cher, ray ban uk, nike huarache, sac vanessa bruno, barbour, converse pas cher, ray ban pas cher, nike air max, abercrombie and fitch, vans outlet, michael kors canada

oakleyses said...

uggs on sale, babyliss pro, chi flat iron, jimmy choo shoes, canada goose uk, nfl jerseys, celine handbags, asics shoes, p90x workout, moncler, mcm handbags, mont blanc pens, insanity workout, north face outlet, canada goose pas cher, ghd, moncler outlet, lululemon outlet, valentino shoes, soccer jerseys, herve leger, giuseppe zanotti, wedding dresses, instyler ionic styler, soccer shoes, birkin bag, ugg outlet, ugg boots, baseball bats, north face jackets, iphone 6 case, bottega veneta, marc jacobs outlet, moncler, moncler, rolex watches, new balance outlet, uggs outlet, reebok shoes, ugg, nike air max, beats headphones, canada goose outlet, canada goose, abercrombie and fitch, ugg soldes, canada goose outlet, canada goose outlet, ferragamo shoes, hollister clothing