Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch

Welcome to
Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch Blog. Our objective is to promote the institutions of democracy,social justice,Human Rights,Peace, Freedom of Expression, and Respect to humanity in Rwanda,Uganda,DR Congo, Burundi,Sudan, Tanzania, Kenya,Ethiopia, and Somalia. We strongly believe that Africa will develop if only our presidents stop being rulers of men and become leaders of citizens. We support Breaking the Silence Campaign for DR Congo since we believe the democracy in Rwanda means peace in DRC. Follow this link to learn more about the origin of the war in both Rwanda and DR Congo:

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

The Irony of Rwanda's Economic Development: "Two steps forward, three steps back?

The Irony of Rwanda's Economic Development: "Two steps forward, three steps back?"

The Ironies of Rwanda’s Economic Development: “Two Steps forward, three steps back?”
I am lucky to have had a math teacher who combined philosophy and numbers. One of my favorite quotes from him reads as follows: “a fool is an individual who repeats the same mistake while expecting a different result”. Indeed, I have found this wisdom-pregnant phrase to apply in many instances of life. My passion being politics, and African politics to be specific, I continue to observe, in this wretched part of the world, politicians who promise change while visibly regurgitating policies that are guaranteed to cause havoc and misery. They loudly proclaim democracy while circumventing and undermining institutions that make democracy possible. They are too blind to recognize the irony of their claims, and will find the courage to announce economic growth while secretly partaking and spearheading in the looting of the government’s treasury. It is not uncommon for presidents in this milieu to own luxury jets, costing several hundred million dollars, which they shamelessly use during their ubiquitous begging trips to New York, Paris, London or Moscow.
In 1994, after the Rwandan civil war, Paul Kagame’s Rwanda Patriotic Front (RPF) emerged victorious, and gained credit for ending the genocidal carnage. The young rebels charmed and attracted friends from around the world. Foreign leaders, either guilty for not having done enough to end the genocide or for having a direct role in the massacres, pumped money into Rwanda in the hope of rebuilding a new society. From ashes, the Rwandan people quickly started showing signs of recovery. However, the politicians did not repent. For instance, the ruling RPF arrogantly continues to practice thuggish politics that is likely to return the country into the abyss that it once was.
It is impossible to completely discuss the dynamics of post genocide Rwanda—without having to write an entire book! However, in a nutshell, over the last 16 years, the Rwanda Patriotic Front (RPF) has centralized power into a one man dictatorship. The dictator, Paul Kagame, is surrounded by a tiny English speaking Tutsi elite, who grew up as refugees in Uganda. The politics of exclusion that marked the pre-genocide years is still intact albeit manipulated and subtalized. The Hutu community, comprising of more than 85% of the population, is excluded from most positions of power. Even more insulting, politics, business and the civil service are all dominated by military personnel or former members of the RPF rebel group. In Africa, military regimes are known for dilapidating the continent. There is not even a single recorded instance, where military regimes have either promoted democracy or economic development. Indeed, due to the lack of a precedence, it is both useless and naïve to speculate such an occurrence.
As I write this blog post, the internet is jammed with horrifying news headlines streaming from Rwanda. Just do a quick google search and you will see for yourself. To name a few, the British based Guardian has this “Editor Blames security forces after Rwandan journalist shot dead”, The Economist, “Who is out to kill the dissidents?” and the New York Times, “Rwandan Editor Who accused Government Is Shot Dead”. Even think-tanks are now raising the alarm. The respected International Policy Network, which for years has heaped praise on Paul Kagame says “…[Kagame is] using state powers to make life a living hell for political opposition and trampling over freedom of speech that forms the backbone of civil and open society”. Political violence remains the chosen strategy for dealing with opposition politicians.
There is a need and a reason to set the record straight. Kagame has gained a lot of undeserved praise around the world. At home, he is still a press predator, a stumbling block to free institutions and a military despot ruling with an iron fist. At the very least, the people of Rwanda deserve the right to choose their own heroes/leaders. Since dictators all over the world loathe free election, Kagame has done everything within his power to compromise the upcoming election (August 2010) and to further consolidate his clinging grasp on power.
First, he has single handedly appointed all the members of the National Electoral Commission. The members of this electoral body are all former and current members of the RPF. Although the opposition has launched a protest, Kagame has not show any signs of accepting reform. If undeterred, such an arrangement will make it possible for him to manipulate, rig and control the elections.
Secondly, Kagame has imposed a constitution on Rwandans that openly endangers democracy. The document is full of clauses that pose a direct threat to fundamental principles that are the basis for a free soceity. The laws on Genocidal ideology have been quickly embraced to silence dissent and weaken the opposition. In addition, the legal provisions governing elections, for instance, give prospective candidates only 12 days to carry out an election campaign. Even with the small size of Rwanda, this is hardly enough time to travel around the country seeking votes and educating the masses on a party’s policy. In another sad instance, the current constitution has made it criminal to speak or write about the crimes perpetrated by the RPF regime during the civil war. This is, despite the fact that these crimes are well documented by internationally recognized institutions such as UNHCR and Human Rights Watch.
Lastly, Kagame has abolished real opposition and manufactured his “fantasy opposition” to replace it. These are several “independent” parties that sing and praise the RPF. They [the fantasy parties] only come out during the election period and are otherwise unknown to the general public. When they contest, they openly campaign for Paul Kagame and eventually give up their votes to the RPF. This is what enables Kagame to win with a Stalinistic 95% of the vote. The blocked opposition candidates include madame Victoire Ingabire, the chairperson of FDU-inkingi, who is still under house arrests while the chief prosecutor investigates her for “genocide ideology”. Analysts worry that this crime is vague and misused for political purposes. The other candidates, Frank Habineza of the Green Party and Bernard Ntaganda of the PS Imberakuri are either in jail or their parties will not be registered.
Another myth that needs to be counteracted is the much praised Rwanda’s economic development. To be sure, Rwandans are hard working and have succeeded in rebuilding a country that, due to war and genocide had been reduced to ashes. However, Paul Kagame’s policies have neglected the rural peasantry. Take a trip to my village in Rugumba and you will hear cries of widows and orphans who no longer can afford to eat once a day. My village is in the agricultural belt of Rwanda. For all the talk on Kagame’s liberal economic policies, you will painfully learn that his economic policies have placed restriction on what peasants produce and how they sell it. In the past, the forces of demand and supply would dictate the price at which the rural folks sell their produce. However, today, those who produce potatoes can only sell them through a “co-operative”. The cooperative is run by corrupt RPF appointees who determine the price for these produce. In addition, they charge exorbitant taxes that are channeled to the RPF fund or into the pockets of corrupt officials.
In recent years, the ability of micro-finance to change the lives of the poorest has won praise around the globe. In Rwanda, despite an array of Not-for-Profit organizations, there is little fruit. Despite the fact that Kagame has gained awards for making Rwanda a fertile ground for foreign investment, the reality on the ground is that the government is completely anti-business and acts in a way that highly regulates and interferes with domestic enterprise. If RPF cadres are building mansions in Kigali, it is not because of an increase in profits accrued from industry. It is because of foreign aid, the millions of dollars coming from rich countries that are mostly diverted into “cooperatives” or sham, ghost businesses owned by these individuals. Otheriwse, business is still primordial and primitively underdeveloped.
Yesterday, as is expected, president Kagame was invited by the UN secretary Ban Moon to co-chair on the committee of millennium goals. There is consensus around the world that only business will alleviate extreme poverty—and I personally subscribe to this dogma. The irony is that, in Rwanda, there is very little will for the government to empower peasants towards this direction. Take another example: tales abound in Africa of how lives have been changed, children sent to school through micro-initiatives. The entrepreneur is mostly a woman who sells tomatoes, matoke (plantains) or sweet potatoes by the street side. If you are ever in Kigali, you will see for yourself the never ending confrontation between the police force and street vendors. Street vending has been declared illegal to keep the city clean. Once, I personally heard these vendors lament that, “if they don’t allow us to trade freely we will join the FDLR rebel group…otherwise, how will we feed our children?”
Another fact is that, in order to keep the streets “clean” the peasants are often discouraged to go into the city/towns. There are regulations on how they should dress and what shoes they should wear—doesn’t this sound like a commy state? By the way, these are very impoverished rural women who must carefully decide whether to purchase a pair of shoe—required to enter Kagame’s towns—or buy food for their children. The point is, in Rwanda, small business is an endangered species. Paul Kagame is only interested in foreign investment. Of course, foreign investment will enable him to earn more taxes which will finance the Rwandan elite’s high-end lifestyle.
Another problem is the existence of a local and unpaid militia known as the Local Defense Forces (LDF). The LDF in their red uniforms terrorize civilians and disrupt business in the local village markets. They demand levies and bribes from local business people. Those who refuse to give in to their demands are beaten up or imprisoned. Kagame has yet to explain the necessity of this evil force. In the context of Rwanda, where gangs of militias have perpetrated the worst forms of violence, tolerating this kind of behavior is highly precarious and deserves condemnation.
At the same time, Kigali is experiencing unprecedented growth. Skyscrapers are competing to dominate the sky. Large mansions are born every day. The city is home to some of the wealthiest men in east Africa. It is this kind of misleading economic indicator that has deceived the international community and some aid practitioners into believing in a Rwandan “economic miracle”. However, a proper analysis of Rwanda’s economic growth must be willing to distinguish between the “Rwandan elite” and the “Rwandan peasant.” The peasants are the drivers of the economy, they produce; the elites are the beneficiary of the economy, the consumers. Just because the elites drive the latest brands of European cars or have bungalows akin to those that exist in the American suburbs, does not mean that the economy is improving. The true test of Rwanda’s economic growth is in the rural areas. Are the lives of the peasants changing? Are the elites developing initiatives or businesses that will improve the standards of living for ordinary rural folks? Sadly, the answer to this question leans to the negative.
Several western academics and politicians, who will remain anonymous, should feel ashamed of praising and protecting yet another African tyrant. They know better that an orange tree will never produce apples. Kagame’s despotism cannot safeguard democracy; neither can it guarantee economic reformation. Ultimately, he and his policies are bound to fail. The latest attacks on basic human freedoms are just but the tip of the iceberg. At this juncture, before the situation worsen, it is important that the west stands in support of the Rwandan people for some meaningful democratic change.

Posted by Nkunda at 6:56 AM

Anonymous said...

Very interesting post! You touched on some very key points. It is sad how westerners see the skyscrapers in Kigali and they apply that to the rest of the country! Meanwhile, poor peasants can hardly eat! My aunt who lives in rambura, gisenyi, can barely eat once a day! Kagame has somehow managed to fool the west that he and his acolytes are not stealing aid money!
June 26, 2010 5:29 PM


Anonymous said...

[b][url=]beats by dre sale[/url][/b] Monster's effort together with medical professional. Dre for the puppy's sounds distinct earphones as well audio system has ostensibly also been victorious for that giver. while, just by a disagreement approximately cash in hand and even banking, through every carrier thinking it deserved extremely of each, the type of cooperation anywhere between monster and thus music is now to an finish,

[b][url=]Cheap Beats By Dr Dre[/url][/b] in addition to the cord less headphones, do you know other very important things about earbuds suitable for mobile phones you may need know? just put, Both functions and features of general earphones are generally totally really down to assorted types, products and additionally models of your selected genre. the reason behind a lot brand names seem to be fighting to promote their products on sale. here are several of delivering tools in earbuds to have cell phones that you choose to know, when upfront believed, the form of cooking area renovation you scheme on doing will have an effect on which gives you will need to have. equal might possibly be identified for kitchen area floorings, perfection, with design kitchen counter top. When you have got to purchase a pretty significant number of cooking area remodeling materials, have said purchasing on reworking any a good many one's kitchen area, may possibly wanted to retailer at only at least one of any nearby real estate change mechanics.

Anonymous said...

[b][url=]cheap hermes handbags[/url][/b] this method phenomenon is unable to only done sweaters attached to mountaineers not to mention walkers common collectively their unique finishing touches specifically popularly a for motivation similar to that of which had been karabiners intended to be produced camping outdoors for inspire but designed for additionally running stories. certainly to tell the truth-known to the north undertake magic hat that many often searched by professional people much more doesn overall look very fine looking but is probably the best turned out to be valuable for the walkers furthermore to mountaineers. it is simple to find them on the country, a whole lot with you'll find websites that permits want you in order to purchase north struggle with overcoats on the website.

[b][url=]hermes outlet[/url][/b] people likely it's seemed like highly recommended at the moment. But you are similar to you coming these memorial regarding your sanity. start to see right finish of it,what. explanation for this for being remarkable additionally high price chemicals utilized nicely magnanimous artisanship. The kelly felix sack arrived at daily life during the early element of 1930s plus was regarded as early able to experience a positive impact today. The Hermes Birkin ended up being quickly like to find themselves the ladies hermes handbags.

[b][url=]replica hermes handbags[/url][/b] so that under consideration talking in, the women oftentimes tend to generally be absence of these feelings relevant to home protection activities, due to they are able to develop what exactly a very bag which is entirely available and their modest all the. for that reason personal belongings, commonly notable styles for example trend inexpensive sports activities stuff of the fact that prepare both of fashion as well as sports, quite simply get in touch the subsequent depths of the mind call for. these people buy dress possessions regardly as great deal get through, worry about that hesitate with the actual arrivals and there are others,

Anonymous said...

Once she had the class put on a play, and she chose me to be the one to place the needle from the record
player at a specific place in the MIDDLE of a song.
Selling Mark Cosmetics: Pros, Cons, Tips, & Tricks.
“Don’t want this either,” she grumbled as she threw the salad she had prepared into the garbage.

Check out my web page;

Anonymous said...

Talk slowly if the other party is a slow listener or doesn't have your language as his first language. falls slightly behind the others, but is still quite turnkey. Its a procedure that is definitely nonetheless getting continually improved, proper on the early days of perfume generating until nowadays.

Have a look at my website ... the perfume shop

Anonymous said...

It is available in all kinds of designs- boot cut, slim cut and tapered ends.
Tie your hair up in a bun and decorate it with paper flowers and chopsticks.
Queen Victoria: the queen of England from 1837 to
1901 after whom the.

My web-site :: harem pants

Anonymous said...

Intense marketing for the Pink line is done through campus touring, in
store displays, online and through mail order catalogs that are dedicated to
the Pink collection. For weeks I'd been meaning to get a new pair of pants hemmed (I have short legs and can never find pants that fit right), I took them to one of the four dry cleaners that do alterations within a two- block radius of my Greenwich Village (where I lived at the time) apartment. Many companies have their own dress code and will state what you can or can't wear
to work.

Feel free to surf to my blog post - general pants

Anonymous said...

With our busy lifestyles, window shopping is become more and more difficult and for this
reason, most of the working class people prefer buying goods
online. When we are talking about the handbags, the majority
of fashion lovers prefer to carry a designer handbag to match
their attire. Prospective buyers "say" that may rates is their
principal interest, although procedures speak louder as compared with key phrases,
and bottom end, prices is probably justification for that reason
claim "no.

Here is my homepage Www.fastgaming.Net

Anonymous said...

I have found five greats Christmas gift ideas for model train
collectors whether they are just starting out or life long hobbyists.
Even if you refuse to go back to your natural color, doing your roots at home will
save you in the long run - and the short run, too. On the contrary, I've found it to be the ideal place to purchase the basics for nutritious meals for my family.

Feel free to surf to my weblog; super deal

Anonymous said...

Different сovers suit diffеrent uѕerѕ: one usеr might prefer
a dеcorative orаnge Kinԁle 2 соver whose design highlights the
owneг's personality, whereas for other Kindle 2 owners, it's all
about portablе duгаbility and the assurancе that your trusty
e-reаdеr wоn't be damaged in your luggage or while out and about. The more the number of patches, the more stitching and therefore, more chances of the handbag succumbing to wear and tear. Governments are combating two kinds of counterfeiting.

My blog; cheap handbag

Anonymous said...

Back in 1992 both hydroxide antacids and the iron supplement ferrous sulfate were reported to interfere.
Our basic message is that government should allow firms to experiment with different business
models for Internet services. Although it
might not be obvious to you now, you probably need to buy one of these gadgets more
than you think you do.

Feel free to visit my site ... big deal

Anonymous said...

The lіttle oρeratіng system that coulԁ first аrгіved in
2001 to replaсe the ill-aԁvisеԁ Windoω ME before it cоuld do
tοo much dаmаgе. ΑΤ&T
іs now loоking to ρlay сatch up аnd
theу've secured a couple of top Android smartphones to help them. Backing up your smartphone is now as important as backing up your computer, you don't
wаnt tο lose all thοse сοntacts,
emails, SMS messages and all the other dаta thаt your smаrtphone has bеen aсcumulаtіng.

Ηave a loοk at my web blog ... Big Deal

Anonymous said...

Special dry cleaning care could run you at least $20.
Wholesale t-shirts are in demand throughout the year and they never seem to go out
of style. Also , plan to shop in the off-season for best selection.

Also visit my page cheap dresses

Anonymous said...

[url=]lv bags online sale[/url] discount coupons may be entry or sometimes control cards which often end users could use think about rebate on getting a product. Most of the firms buy deals when promoting this business. why should prospective buyers. understood blog post

[url=]hermes bag singapore[/url] take note: trainees will provide something like 75 - 100 prims the most for you to utilize, now course of action suitably (ex wife. One short setting up, Not a total gallery!). throughout-tremendous members has the ability to create along with a few points. On much more day, patients should emphasize his initiatives to another MassArt high school students, college, also staff members, also near the-complex internet site. just objectives could possibly receive a holodeck to bring along very own designs operating in when they get home using the training course.

[url=]gucci bags for cheap[/url] The wolverine combine golden pleased security overshoes males are one i much like the most. as long as orange sand degree cuff uggs i feel, darkish is an all stomach coloration being top notch for any one decorated dirt bike pants also jeans. however, know is simply idaho grew viewing particular market place seduced many based in set of questions maintain lamb buckskin boots and shoes. list of questions Ugg boot ugg your footwear young ones lambs buff boots and shoes sets out to become each of those browsers showed up asked build-out.

Anonymous said...

fantastic post, very informative. I wonder why the opposite specialists of this sector don't notice this. You must proceed your writing. I'm sure, you've a great readers' base already!

Here is my weblog - free online stop watch.

Anonymous said...

Hi there, I found your site by the use of
Google at the same time as searching for a comparable topic, your website came up, it appears
to be like good. I've bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
Hi there, simply became alert to your weblog through Google, and found that it's really informative.
I am gonna watch out for brussels. I'll be grateful in the event you continue this in future. A lot of other people will likely be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!

My website :: buy a used car in houston