Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch



Welcome to
Africa Great Lakes Democracy Watch Blog. Our objective is to promote the institutions of democracy,social justice,Human Rights,Peace, Freedom of Expression, and Respect to humanity in Rwanda,Uganda,DR Congo, Burundi,Sudan, Tanzania, Kenya,Ethiopia, and Somalia. We strongly believe that Africa will develop if only our presidents stop being rulers of men and become leaders of citizens. We support Breaking the Silence Campaign for DR Congo since we believe the democracy in Rwanda means peace in DRC. Follow this link to learn more about the origin of the war in both Rwanda and DR Congo:http://www.rwandadocumentsproject.net/gsdl/cgi-bin/library


Thursday, January 12, 2012

RWANDA:Dr. Thoegene Rudasingwa Responds to French Report on Rwanda: We Shall Win!

Responding to the French Judge Marc Trevidic's technical report.
Dr. Thoegene Rudasingwa
Dr. Thoegene Rudasingwa

(WASHINGTON D.C.) - On the 1st October 2011, I published a confession in which I stated that Paul Kagame, then overall commander of the Rwandese Patriotic Army, the armed wing of the Rwandese Patriotic Front, was personally responsible for the shooting down of the plane on April 6, 1994, in which President Juvenal Habyarimana of Rwanda.
Others killed in the crash:

President Cyprian Ntaryamira of Burundi
Deogratias Nsabimana
Elie Sagatwa
Thaddee Bagaragaza
Emmanuel Akingeneye
Bernard Ciza
Cyriaque Simbizi
Jacky Heraud
Jean-Pierre Minaberry
Jean-Michel
I stated that Paul Kagame himself had told me, in July 1994, that he was responsible for the shooting down of the plane. I stated that Paul Kagame has to be brought to account for his role in this terrorist crime that provided a trigger for the 1994 genocide in Rwanda.
Rwanda Pres. Paul Kagame
I have also stated that myself and other witnesses are willing, able, and ready to provide further evidence to national or/and international jurisdictions interested in contributing to truth, justice, reconciliation and healing in Rwanda.
Neither myself nor other new, willing, and able witnesses have yet been able to meet Judge Marc Trevidic, or any other international tribunal/court. to give the true account of the events surrounding the shooting down of the plane.
Today, 10th January, 2012, the French Judge, Marc Trevidic, investigating the 1994 terrorist crime, made public the findings of the Technical Report by ballistic experts. Among other things, the technical report stated that:
Rwanda Pres. Juvenal Habyarimana
    a) the experts were leaning more towards the version of the events that the missile that shot down the plane originated from several areas, especially around the Kanombe area in Kigali;
    b) the missiles were made and supplied from the former Soviet Union and,
    c) lawyers and other interested parties have up to three months to contest any matters arising from the report.
In this regard, I would like to state the following:
1. That the missile was fired from a number of areas in the Kanombe area does not exonerate Paul Kagame from having committed the crime;
2. That the missiles were of Soviet Union origin will prove to be of substantive help in establishing who the real culprit is, and;
3. That there is time for us ( myself and other interested and new witnesses) to respond fully to the technical report and provide credible testimony to Judge Marc Trevidic, or any other in the international jurisdiction, to pin down Paul Kagame as the culprit in this terrorist crime.
The wreckage of President Juvenal Habyarimana's plane.
I stand fully behind the letter and spirit of my October 1st, 2011 confession. Judge Marc Trevidic’s technical report has not proved me wrong. Nor has it exonerated Paul Kagame from this crime, and yet Kigali is spinning the story out of context to celebrate what it calls “victory”. In the coming months and years, myself, other witnesses, Rwandans and others in the international community who heed the call, will continue to endeavor to have Paul Kagame account for his role in this and other crimes.
I would like to remind all Rwandans and the international community that this is not Judge Marc Trevidic’s final judgment on the matter. Furthermore, matters of truth and justice for Rwandans will primarily be decided by us Rwandans. Even when the international community and foreigners in general have had the reputation of disappointing Rwandans, we must have faith in our struggle for truth, justice, healing, and reconciliation.
Let us mobilize and organize, for truth and justice shall ultimately prevail.
We shall win.
Dr. Theogene Rudasingwa
Editor's note: The final report has not been made public. Upon its publication the link will be provided in the comments of this article.
_________________________________
Submitted by: Jennifer Fierberg, MSW; a correspondent, Assistant Editor, and Volunteer Coordinator for NGO News Africa through the volunteer project of the UN. and Salem-News.com. Jennifer is also the media co-coordinator and senior funding executive for The Africa Global Village (www.africaglobalvillage.com)

RWANDA:Réponse au Rapport Technique du Juge Français Marc Trévidic sur l'incident d'avion de Habyarimana Juvenal

WASHINGTON DC, LE 10 JANVIER 2012

Le 1er octobre 2011, j’ai communiqué au public une confession dans laquelle j’ai indiqué que Paul Kagame était responsable de la destruction le 6 avril 1994, de l’avion à bord duquel se trouvaient les Présidents Juvénal Habyarimana du Rwanda, Cyprien Ntaryamira du Burundi, ainsi que Messieurs Déogratias Nsabimana, Elie Sagatwa, Thaddée Bagaragaza, Emmanuel Akingeneye, Bernard Ciza, Cyriaque Simbizi, Jacky Hérault, Jean-Pierre Minaberry, et Jean-Michel qui furent tous tués. J’ai indiqué que Paul Kagame en personne m’avait dit qu’il était responsable des tirs qui ont abattu l’avion. J’ai dit que Paul Kagame devait répondre de son rôle dans ce crime terroriste qui est l’élément qui a déclenché le génocide de 1994 au Rwanda. J’ai également déclaré que moi-même, ainsi que d’autres témoins étions disposés, capables et prêts pour fournir des informations supplémentaires aux juridictions nationales et/ou internationales qui seraient intéressées pour contribuer à la vérité, à la justice, à la réconciliation et au processus de guérison au Rwanda.

Ni moi-même, ni aucun autre des nouveaux témoins capables et disposés n’avons pu rencontrer le Juge Marc Trévidic, ou tout autre Tribunal international pour leur donner les vraies informations sur les évènements relatifs aux tirs qui ont abattu l’avion.

Aujourd’hui, le 10 janvier 2012, le Juge français marc Trévidic chargé de l’enquête sur le crime terroriste de 1994, a rendu publiques les conclusions du rapport technique fournies par des experts en balistique. Le rapport affirme notamment que a) les experts penchent plus vers la version des fait selon laquelle le missile qui a abattu l’avion serait parti de plusieurs endroits et en particulier des environs de Kanombe a Kigali ; que b) les missiles étaient de fabrication russe et avaient été livrés par l’Ancienne Union Soviétique ; et que c) les avocats et les autres parties intéressées ont jusqu’à trois mois pour contester tout éléments relatif au rapport.

A cet égard, je voudrais souligner ce qui suit :
1. Le fait que les missiles aient été tiré des environs de la zone de Kanombe ne signifie nullement que Kagame n’a pas commis le crime ;
2. Le fait que les missiles étaient d’origine soviétique constitue un élément technique essentiel pour déterminer le véritable coupable ; et
3. Nous avons encore le temps, (moi-même et les autres témoins intéressés et nouveaux) pour répondre intégralement au rapport technique et donner des témoignages crédibles au juge Marc Trévidic ou à toute autre juridiction internationale, pour démontrer avec précision que Kagame est l’auteur de ce crime terroriste.

Je confirme avec force l’esprit et la lettre de ma confession du 1er octobre 2011. Le rapport du Juge Marc Trévidic n’a en rien démenti ce que j’ai dit. Pas plus qu’il n’a lavé Paul Kagame de son crime même si Kigali est en train de sortir l’affaire de son contexte pour célébrer ce qu’ils appellent une « victoire ». Dans les tous prochains moins et années, moi-même, les autres témoins, les rwandais ainsi que d’autres personnes de la communauté internationale qui entendent l’appel, allons continuer à faire en sorte que Kagame réponde de son rôle dans ce crime et dans plusieurs autres actes criminels.

Je tiens à souligner à l’attention de tous les rwandais et de la communauté internationale que ce rapport ne constitue pas un jugement sans appel du juge Marc Trévidic sur cette affaire. Par ailleurs, pour les rwandais, les questions relatives à la vérité et à la justice seront réglées en premier lieu par nous, les rwandais. Même confrontés au fait que la communauté internationale et les étrangers en général se sont illustrés en décevant les rwandais, nous devons avoir foi dans notre lutte pour la vérité, la justice, la réconciliation et le processus de guérison.

Nous devons nous mobiliser et nous organiser, car la vérité et la justice finiront par prévaloir. Nous vaincrons !

Dr. Théogène Rudasingwa
E-mail: ngombwa@gmail.com

RWANDA: INDEGE YA HABYARIMANA YARASIWE MASAKA NA FPR IBIFASHIJWEMO NA MINUAR

by Tingiting Survivors on Wednesday, 11 January 2012 at 08:41

Falcon-50 ya Habyarimana yarasiwe Masaka na FPR sous protection ya MINUAR

Misile zarashe Falcon-50 ya Habyarimana ni SAM 16,The Heat-seeking Missile, nkuko bivugwa na rapport zitandukanye izomisile zikoresha seeker ya IR guidance system ( iflared guidance system) or Heat guidance system, byumvikane ko ziraswa muri field iri inyuma Engeen, kuko zikurikira ubushyuhe buturuka muri Moteur y'indege, ntibishoboka ko zaba zararasiwi Mu kigo i Kanombe bitewe n'aho indege yaguye, iyo zirasirwa i Kanombe indege yari kurenga ikibuga ikagwa munce za Remera, kuko bari kuyirasa imaze yabura gucaho, bityo indege yabasiwe Masaka, ukurikije Barsics Law and  Heat guidance properties.
Nk'uko bigaragazwa n'impuguke,  zishingiye ku buhamya bw'abazungu bari i Kanombe mu kigo, bashingiye kuri ACCOUSTICS rules, bavuga ko missile zaba zaraturutse mu kigo, Hariho probability nke cyane ko SAM_16 yarasa indege iyituruste i mbere mu ruhande, ntabwo hashingirwa ku batangabuhamya batatu b'abazungu gusa cyaba ari ikinyoma

RWANDA: FDU-INKINGI and RNC still believe that the responsibility of President Paul Kagame in the downing of his predecessor's plane is real.

PRESS RELEASE

FDU-INKINGI and RNC still believe that the responsibility of President Paul Kagame in the downing of his predecessor's plane is real.

Today, French judges, Marc Trevedic and Natalie Poux, disclosed a first technical Report by ballistic experts to the parties in the probe related to the downing of the April1994 presidential plane that killed President Juvenal Habyarimana of Rwanda and President Cyrpien Ntaryamira of Burundi, members of their delegations and the French crew. The same time, the government of Rwanda removed the embargo on its ready-made press release celebrating “victory”. The same evening some medias echoed the version of Lawyer Bernard Maingain, who represents President Paul Kagame's entourage who were under investigation, saying that the findings "put an end to more than 16 years of manipulation and lies." This is a well prepared media campaign aiming to fool national and international opinion in order to polish the dictator's version.

The technical report by ballistic experts has investigated 6 possible launching sites according to the information surveyed in Kigali during their investigations. The question of where the ground-to-air missile was fired is a key to establishing the credibility of different accounts of the terrorist attack. Curiously, the Rwandan government has just picked up one possible launching spot as the one and only one to be considered. This is what the regime is selling to international media in order to avoid other aspects pointing at the real masterminder of the attack.

Considering the level of infiltrations and deployments of operatives in Kigali city and its surroundings by the then rebellion, we have no single doubts that RPF was in a position to mount such an operation in most of the six suspected firing spots.

This first technical report does not change anything from the truth. Our respective organisations are committed to identify very credible witnesses ready to provide details and facts of the operation and the operatives under orders of the then rebel military overall commander.

In the past, there have been several rival accounts of this terrorist attack and only an international inquiry composed by experts from different countries will pave the way to justice denied.

This white-washing media campaign launched by Kigali regime pointing the finger at its eternal enemies, Hutu extremists, is trying to distract the international community from the real problems of the country on the brink. The current leadership has been accused by the United Nations report of the Mapping Exercise documenting the most serious violations of human rights and international humanitarian law committed within the territory of the Democratic Republic of the Congo between March 1993 and June 2003. There is no political space in Rwanda and freedoms are massively violated. Most partners of Rwanda have voiced out their concerns over continuous violations of human rights, the plight of political prisoners, assassinations of opposition leaders and journalists inside and outside the country, life attempts against exiled opposition leaders.

We encourage the French justice to continue its investigations and call for an international inquiry in this terrorist attack.

Lausanne, Switzerland

Dr. Nkiko Nsengimana
Co-ordinator,
FDU-Inkingi Co-ordination Committee
Contact: nkiko.nsengimana@bluewin.ch or sixchris@netti.fi

Washington D.C., USA

Dr. Theogene Rudasingwa
Co-ordinator
RNC Interim Committee
Contact: ngombwa@gmail.com

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

RWANDA: IF KAGAME WAS WISE ENOUGH HE WOULD HAVE MADE RWANDA A BILINGUAL COUNTRY LIKE CAMEROON WHERE ALL OF US ARE FLUENT IN BOTH ENGLISH AND FRENCH TO COMPETE IN GLOBAL MARKET

From African Dictator, please publish this New Times story in it’s entirety for your readers. I don’t know whether to laugh or cry. The story shows how Rwanda is impulsively run by this man Kagame. He wanted Rwanda to speak English overnight by decree. But there no English teachers in the country.
Then he tried to have the teachers taught English in holidays, and the whole exercise fell flat. Remember these Rwandan teachers earn about US$50 a month.
Then Kagame came up with an bird brain scheme. He ordered the recruitment of English teachers from Kenya – 4,000 of them so that every Rwandan primary and secondary school gets a Kenyan teacher to teach the teachers English.
The Kenyans will find 200 Ugandan teachers previously deployed by Kagame.
Though supposed to start in January 2012, we are told that the Kenyans will arrive “as soon as possible”.
I ask people to read this story please and very carefully. See what the Minister of Education says. See what the Rwandan Ambassador in Kenya says. It’s all insane.
You will no doubt ask yourself – “are these people for real”? “who is in charge in Rwanda”?
I am sad to my country.
Kagame’s children study in America and the younger ones study in Kagame wife’s school Green Hills Academy with its foreign and well-paid teachers.This man has messed the education system in our country and we are paying the consequences. And he really does not care, to use his favorite phrase.
The question is, what are we to do honestly?
4,000 English teachers to be recruited by FebruaryBy Stevenson Mugisha
Kagame Minister Mathias Harebamungu

English teachers that were meant to be recruited by the Ministry of Education at the start of this academic year, which starts next week, are now expected into the country next month.According to the ministry, the teachers will all be recruited from Kenya. The recruitment is being facilitated by both governments at the ministerial level in collaboration with Kenya’s Teachers’ Service Commission, and Rwanda Education Board.
This was revealed yesterday by the State Minister in charge of Primary and Secondary Education, Dr Mathias Harebamungu.
According to the minister, the teachers are being recruited to train their Rwandan counterparts how best they can improve their English proficiency, both spoken and written.
He noted that the ministry intends to deploy at least one teacher at every school (primary and secondary) across the country. Each would  be responsible for training teachers in the English subject.
This is part of the implementation of the government policy of using English as the language of instruction at all levels of education in the country.
“We have been conducting English training for teachers at end-of-year holidays (November and December), which was not giving us the desired output, hence hiring these people,” Harebamungu said.
He said that having qualified English teachers based at their respective schools will no doubt improve the tutors’ English, which they will impart to their students.
According to Harebamungu, the hired teachers will have open contracts;
“we will only discharge them after our teachers have mastered the language.”
Harebamungu also noted that apart from teaching the teachers, those to be recruited will also organise drama and English debate competitions in their schools to improve students’ confidence in the language.
Meanwhile, the minister dispelled rumours that the Kenyan teachers will be paid as expatriates, saying that none of these teachers will exceed a monthly remuneration of Rwf200,000.
He added that there are also over 200 English teachers from Uganda who are currently teaching English in the country.
In a phone interview with The New Times yesterday, Rose Muchiri, the High Commissioner of Kenya to Rwanda, said they are working around the clock to ensure that the teachers arrive as soon as possible.
“I am optimistic that this process will be completed very soon, courtesy of the existing good bilateral relations between our two countries” Muchiri said.
steven.mugusha@newtimes.co.rw

Monday, January 9, 2012

RWANDA:Rwanda Gets French Report On Habyarimana Plane Disaster


KILLED: Habyarimana KILLED: Habyarimana in a Plane from Arusha TANZANI

By
Rwanda President Paul Kagame has received a copy of the long-awaited report on the April 6, 1994 shooting down of the plane carrying Juvenal Habyarimana.

French judges Marc Trevidic and Nathalie Poux, who have been investigating the incident which sparked genocide in Rwanda, forwarded the report to Kigali on January 7.
Government immediately wired the report to Kagame’s aides in South Africa where he is attending the ANC’s 100th Anniversary celebrations, according to well placed sources in Kigali.
Details of the report, which will be made public this week, are still scanty.
The two judges have been investigating the sensitive incident following the retirement of Judge Bruguiere.
The contents of the report are so crucial given that the judges will officially indict perpetrators of the assassination and issue public arrest warrants.
Kigali is still silent on the matter, raising fears the report could be pinning RPF leaders in the shooting.
Kagame’s former Cabinet Secretary Theogene Rudasingwa shook the world late last year when he revealed the President, who was then the RPF leader, shot down the plane.
Rudasingwa said Kagame on several times told him how he blew up the plane carrying Habyarimana, his Burundian counterpart Cyprien Ntaryamira and their staff.
Kagame denies the allegations.
The investigating judges in September 2010 visited Rwanda where they brought experts to reconstruct the shooting of the plane.
The judges intended to publish the report in March last year but were compelled to postpone to June 2011, fearing the publication would coincide with the sensitive month of April.
Judges further faced a serious diplomatic challenge around June considering that Kagame was planning a visit to France.
The Habyarimana case led to the severing of ties between Rwanda and France. Kigali accused French soldiers of raping Rwandese women during a humanitarian operation in 1994.
France has been investigating the assassination because the pilots of the ill-fated plane were French.
During the Rwanda trip, judges were accompanied by experts in geometry, ballistics, explosives and fires, hoping to determine the area where the missiles were fired.
The judges at the time suspected a commando squad of Rwandan Patriotic Front, the Tutsi rebel group led by Kagame, who seized power immediately after the genocide, had broken the defence lines of the mainly Hutu Rwandan Armed Forces.
Kagame’s government shifts the blame to Hutu extremists within the FAR whom it says wanted to eliminate the president in a coup d’état.
An investigation carried out by British experts shows missiles were fired from a heavily fortified FAR Military base

Saturday, January 7, 2012

RWANDA:Proposed media law fails to safeguard free press




From ARTICLE 19 ONLINE NEWS LETTER
A revised media law promised by the Rwandan government prior to and during its Universal Periodic Review at the UN Human Rights Council in 2011 fails to safeguard the right to freedom of expression and a free media.[1] ARTICLE 19 welcomes several improvements in the draft, but calls on the government to bring the law into full compliance with international legal standards on the right to freedom of expression.
image
The State retains its control over the media in the draft Law by determining rules for its operation and defining journalists’ professional standards. Media freedoms and the right to freedom of expression are not safeguarded and can be restricted in violation of international law due to overbroad definitions and the creation of vaguely defined prohibitions. The Minister in charge of information and communication technologies (ICT) is given unlimited powers to determine the requirements for establishing media outlets and conditions for accepting foreign audio-visual media to operate in Rwanda. ARTICLE 19 is also concerned that the proposed amendments leave untouched problematic provisions in the current Media Law that are not in compliance with international standards.
The draft Law amending the 2009 Media Law of Rwanda includes nine articles covering legal definitions, the right to exercise the profession of a journalist, the right to seek redress, requirements for launching an audio or audiovisual media outlet, licensing for foreign audio visual media organs to operate in Rwanda and penalties for crimes committed through the media. The Media Law is a comprehensive legal act containing ninety-nine provisions which determine “the responsibilities, the structure and functioning of the media.” It regulates the establishment and functioning of media outlets, including Internet publications. In addition, it regulates the status of journalists, outlines press offenses, and describes the liability regime for media and journalists and the rights to correction, reply and refutation.

Positive developments

The draft Law introduces additional definitions to explain the regime established by the Media Law. Another positive feature is the repeal of some problematic definitions concerning the right to reply, the right to rectification, and the right to correction as these are not in compliance with international standards and unnecessarily restrict the right to freedom of expression.[2] ARTICLE 19 considers the following changes to be positive from a freedom of expression point of view:
  • Removal of the requirement that journalists hold particular academic qualifications as this unnecessarily restricts access to the profession[3]
  • Removal of excessively bureaucratic requirements concerning press cards. These may be used as mechanisms through which to control who operates as a journalist[4]
  • Lifting of a number of restrictions on journalists, including the prohibition from “the using of unlawful methods to obtain or to disseminate information”, “neglecting essential information”, “distorting ideas contained in an information or a text”, which are unclear and can be used by the authorities to harass journalists [5]
  • Repeal of the grounds on which the authorities can refuse to provide information as these are not in compliance with international standards[6]
  • Lifting of the requirement for photojournalists to seek authorization by the media authorities to perform their profession[7]
  • Liberalisation of the system of sanctions for the media by repealing the provisions on warning or suspension of a press publication[8] and penalties for irregular press publications[9]
  • Repeal of sanctions of “suspension” and “closure of a publication”, both of which are disproportionate restrictions on the right to freedom of expression[10]. There are always less intrusive forms of sanctions which may be used to ensure the media comply with the Media Law and do not violate the rights of others, for example fines[11].

Continuing problems with the draft Law

At the same time ARTICLE 19 is concerned that the following aspects of the draft Law do not comply with international standards on freedom of expression and information. Firstly, there are a number of problems in respect of the definitions advanced by the Draft Law:
  • The definition of “journalist” is too broad in its scope and covers persons who are not professionally engaged in journalism (such as bloggers and social media users) into the existing media law regime: According to the definition in Article 1 of the draft Law, any person involved in the collection, processing and dissemination of information can be regarded as a journalist. It means that persons such as university researchers, bloggers and social media users, for example, would fall under this broad definition and hence are subject to legal responsibility under the Media Law. It is inappropriate and unnecessary for a media law to regulate non-journalistic activities.
  • The definition of “news item” is overbroad and may be used to hold journalists liable for any information reported by them: The definition “news item” in Article 1 essentially includes any information published or broadcast by the media. The broad definition is dangerous from a freedom of expression point of view since Article 88 of the Media Law provides for criminal responsibility of authors and presenters for offences committed through news items. The broad definition of “news items” means that journalists can be held responsible for any information reported or distributed by them. This violates international standards, which provide individuals with protection for justified opinions (value judgements) and protect journalists from liability for reporting the statements of third parties. ARTICLE 19 is concerned that the unlimited responsibility of authors and presenters will have a chilling effect on free news reporting.[12]
  • The definition of “defamation” is overbroad and may be used to impose liability for the expression of opinions and to restrict in violation of international law certain forms of expression such as satirical publications or other forms of expression which by their nature are exaggerations, and parodies: Article 1 of the draft Law introduces a definition of defamation as “any act of using words, images or pictures published that are not accurate or true with the intention to offend the honour or estimation of the person or expose him/her to public contempt”. This definition can be used to restrict satirical publications or caricatures, which by their nature are exaggerations and parodies. Moreover, ARTICLE 19 is concerned that the definition allows for the imposition of liability for the expression of opinions, rather than for false statements of fact. We recall that international standards require a balance to be struck between the right to freedom of expression on the one hand, and the right of individuals to protect their reputations on the other. However, defamation provisions should not be used to restrict debate on matters in the public interest, particularly as they relate to the conduct of public officials or limit the use of different forms of expression, including those that are satirical.
In addition to the overbroad definitions outlined above, there are a number of substantive amendments made by the draft Law that are also problematic from a freedom of expression perspective:
  • The Minister in charge of ICT has unlimited powers to determine the requirements for establishing media outlets and conditions for accepting a foreign audio-visual media to operate in Rwanda: Article 4 of the draft Law gives powers to the Minister in charge of ICT to determine the requirements for establishing a local or foreign audio or audiovisual media outlets operating in Rwanda. However, no regulatory framework places any limitations on the exercise of this power, leaving all decisions to the discretion of the Minister. The Draft Law provides no safeguards against unnecessary restrictions on media freedom or against the abuse of powers by the Minister. We note that the constitutional principles of separation of powers and protection of human rights require that Parliament as opposed to the Executive legislate on matters concerning human rights including the right to freedom of expression. Furthermore, when regulatory powers are delegated to the executive bodies the legislation should contain safeguards against misuse or abuse of powers by that executive body. These safeguards include guidance for the exercise of the regulatory powers and requirements to engage in consultations with affected stakeholders. There must also be judicial oversight of any executive regulation of the media, to ensure that the executive body is held to account for the misuse or abuse of their powers.[13]
  • Introduction of new offences for example “publication of false information, intended to undermine the morale of Rwanda Defense Forces and the National Police and to endanger national security” or “inciting the army or the national police to insubordination” or “glorification or promotion of massacre, looting, arson, theft, rape, terrorism or treason.” ARTICLE 19 considers that the actus reus (the guilty acts) of these crimes are broadly defined and illegitimate restrictions on freedom of expression.[14] Moreover, ARTICLE 19 notes that the draft penal Code covers these offences.
Finally ARTICLE 19 is concerned that the proposed amendments leave untouched other problematic provisions in the current Media Law that are not in compliance with international standards, including:
  • The determination by the state rather than by media professionals of media professional standards[15]
  • The test of legality of the restriction on the right to freedom of expression set out in Article 17 of the Media Law does not include a requirement to determine the necessity of the restrictions[16]
  • The confidentiality of journalists’ sources is not effectively protected. Courts are able to require journalists to reveal their sources in relation to any legal proceedings, rather than only in the most serious of criminal cases. In contravention of international standards, the Media Law does not provide that information disclosing the identity of a journalist’s source should only be ordered by a court where there is no other reasonable alternative means available for obtaining that information[17]
  • The licensing by the Media High Council of all media rather than limiting licensing to broadcast media only. Licensing of the broadcast media is justified due to demand for broadcast frequencies exceeding the limited number that are available at any one time. However, there is no equivalent technical constraint that justifies imposing a licensing requirement on the print media, or controlling the print media through such a licensing regime[18]
  • The vague powers of the Minister in charge of information to “determine the capital of media outlets”[19]
  • The requirement for authorisation by the Media High Council for Rwandan journalists to become correspondents of foreign media outlets[20]
  • The Media High Council is not independent from government influence because the Minister in charge of information can reverse its decisions[21]
  • The registration regime for the copyright in press publications is not necessary, as copyright under international law does not require registration[22]
  • The unclear requirement for owners of internet cafes to screen and block pornographic websites[23]
  • The excessive fines[24]
  • There is also a lack of clarity regarding the enforcement of the Media Law, in particular it is unclear which bodies have the power to determine press offences and what procedures and procedural safeguards are in effect for the determination of liability and sanctions for those offences.

Changes needed

ARTICLE 19 calls on the Government of Rwanda and all stakeholders to work to incorporate the following recommendations to bring the Media Law into compliance with international standards on freedom of expression and information:  
  1. ARTICLE 19 recommends that the proposed definition of journalist be amended by placing the focus on the nature of the information and specifying that a journalist is a person engaged in information via means of mass communication
  2. There is no need for a definition of a news item. Instead, Article 88 of the current Media Law which includes the expression “news item” should be modified to ensure that journalists and media are not responsible for opinion founded on facts and made in good faith and that they are protected against liability for statements of others
  3. The definition of defamation should be revised so as to apply to any intentional false statement of fact, either written or spoken, that harms a person's reputation
  4. Articles 12, 17, 20, 24, 25, 26, 38, 57 and 78 of the Media Law should be revised and brought in compliance with international law and media standards

RWANDA:It is no Longer Possible to Justify Kagame’s Oppressive Rule in Rwanda

A Story from "Government In the Lab Online Newspaper

RPF Soldiers mutilating a Hutu Woman's Body in DRC, 1997
United State’s militarized foreign policy is difficult to justify, but there are instances in which it can, at least, be rationalized.
Such was the case in the cold war, when the fear for a communist take-over was very palpable. The U.S. jealously defended and promoted democracy. Since liberalism has a universalism component, the freedom or lack of it in one country has effects on other countries.
But the various interventions (well intended or not) did not always embody liberal principles. The ideals of democracy were often betrayed as the invasion of one country to another became the political trend. To be fair, several other countries were involved in this macabre exercise–not just the U.S.
The atrocities committed by western backed despots, especially in Latin America are well documented by now. Though seldom acknowledged, it is very likely that much more damage occurred in Africa, Asia and the Middle East. Just to mention one example, the horrors of what happened in Indonesia under Suharto (Bill Clinton called him “our kind of guy”) are a dark spot in global politics. And so is Rwanda.
However, the cold war is now a matter of history. Communism as a global force is dead and the U.S. is the world’s lone super power. Many were told this would usher a period of peace and stability. But much of the world continues to be broken. Why?
Perhaps a more direct question really is why the U.S. continues to support dictators around the globe. Of what purpose are they serving today?
I admit that dictators are not one homogenic entity. They come in different styles with a wide range of goals. For instance, the rise of Islamic fundamentalism is the new challenge for the west. As far as this is concerned, dictators might still be necessary for US’s immediate goals.
This brings us to Rwanda. Is it necessary to support a dictatorship, in a poor country where almost everyone is pro-American (except Kagame and his military thugs who ironically benefit the most from US’s policies)? Is this the best that the U.S. can offer? The answer is no.
There are many examples in Africa where the U.S. is beginning to aggressively push for democracy. The best regional example is Kenya, where the U.S. is investing heavily in civil society and where the ambassadors are always vocal in support of democracy. This has helped Kenya undergo very crucial reforms, which will probably make it, in a few years, the beacon of hope in the region.
More than every before, this is the decade of democracy triumphalism if there was ever such a thing. Forget Francis Fukuyama and his “End of History”. History is unraveling as we watch in the Middle East and North Africa where dictators are being humbled in a way that would have been previously unthinkable.
The African Spring, although very curtailed by the intricate links with the west that the dictators enjoy, is bound to happen. It is bound to be ruthlessly crushed as well.
Rwanda is a fascinating case for various reasons. For the last 17 years, the U.S. has invested heavily into the country, especially its military. The goal was to transform Kagame’s army from a gang of rebels to professional fighters. The results are unsettling.The army is much more “professional” in preventing the rise of democracy.
In the past, Kagame was seen as a brilliant military strategist. Some might even argue that there was a place in Rwanda’s history for that. But the fighting is now over. A change of how the U.S. handles business with Rwanda is necessary. Otherwise, with the fighting enemies diminished, Kagame may start to target his own people.In deed, the human right situation continues to deteriorate under his rule.
I am trying hard but I really do not see how Kagame’s government can be rationally defended. The so called “economic miracle” that Kagame has been praised for is still a pipe dream. 17 years in power, the Rwandan per capita income is a mediocre $540. Since Rwanda has one of the highest gini-coefficient index in Africa, it is safe (but disturbing) to conclude that the poor are not getting that much.
Another grenade attack occurred in Kigali yesterday. The media reports indicate that at least two people died, and twenty injured. It is possible to see these events as a necessary prerequisite for state formation. However, as a friend told me, this contradicts the image of the “new” Rwanda that some sections of people in the west have been trying to market. The lipstick on the pig is wearing off!
I cannot imagine a solution in Rwanda that will not include some form of western involvement. At the very least, the west can begin by slowly isolating Kagame or being frank to him about the realities of Rwanda’s present. Yet, foreign pressure cannot be substituted for internal movements. The two have to work hand in hand.
It is a new year. As such, anything could happen. Kagame believes he is very strong. In some ways, he deceives himself by reading too much into his press releases. One of my biggest hope is that Rwandans will be able to live in an environment that is safe for them to express choice. This will come to pass. It is just a question of time.
Still, Kagame is heavily dependent on western aid, meaning that the west has a lot of leverage, which it can and should use to influence democratic reform.

Friday, January 6, 2012

RWANDA:COMMUNIQUE DE PRESSE N° 01/P.S.IMB/012

by We Support Rwandan Activists for Truth: The Imberakuri on Friday, 6 January 2012 at 22:19
COMMUNIQUE DE PRESSE N° 01/P.S.IMB/012
Dans la soirée du 03 Janvier 2012, un attentat terroriste à la grenade a eu lieu dans la cellule
de Nyabisindu, secteur de Remera, district de Gasabo dans la ville de Kigali. Les différentes
autorités compétentes déplorent la mort de deux personnes et seize blessés dont certains
grièvement dont Mr Alfred NSENGUMUREMYI, président du parti social IMBERAKURI
dans le secteur de Remera.
Le Parti Social IMBERAKURI se joint aux familles éprouvées par cet acte ignoble. Nous
saisissons également cette occasion pour condamner avec la plus grande énergie toutes ces
forces du mal qui mettent en avant le fait de verser le sang de leurs compatriotes innocents.
Nous demandons également au gouvernement rwandais d’oeuvrer davantage pour la sécurité
de ses citoyens en commençant par apporter des soins adéquats à tous ceux qui ont été blessés
par les éclats de cette grenade au lieu de les refouler « manu militari » sans être soignés dans
le seul but de cacher le nombre exact de victimes.
Le fait que cet attentat ait eu lieu quelques jours seulement après que le gouvernement ait
déployé beaucoup de forces de sécurité (militaires, policiers, local defense units et gardiens de
sécurité) partout dans les quartiers prouve qu’il avait reçu des indices concernant une probable
atteinte à la sécurité nationale. Si tel est le cas, nous saluons cette action de l’Etat en matière
de prévention et anticipation en vue de protéger ses concitoyens et espérons qu’elle va l’aider
à identifier et juger rapidement les auteurs. Par ailleurs, nous osons espérer qu’il ne s’agit pas
d’une façon d’intimider la population tel que ce fut le cas le 15 septembre 2011 lorsque les
forces de police ont tenté d’assassiner par balle Mr Eric NSHYIMYUMUREMYI, président
du parti social IMBEREKURI dans le district de Kicukiro avec la seule intention d’intimider
et faire taire notre parti.
Le Parti Social IMBEREKURI rappelle enfin au gouvernement rwandais que la sécurité de la
population devrait être sa préoccupation principale et qu’une enquête objective et rapide
devrait être rapidement faite pour rassurer les rwandais et les amis du Rwanda.
Fait à Kigali, le 06 Janvier 2012
Alexis BAKUNZIBAKE (sé)
Premier vice-président du parti social IMBERAKURI.

RWANDA: LETA IRARWANIRA NABATURAGE IBIGORI BYOKEJE

Navukiye mu Rwanda, nanubu niho ntuye ariko noneho ibyo ino leta ilimo gukora sinigeze mbibona nahamwe kwisi. Ubu sinemerewe cg se n'Umwana wanjye ngo ntiyemerewe guca ikigori mumulima ngo yose hanyuma asubire kwishuri. Hano mukarere ka RUSIZI kumurenge wa MUGNZA naraye mfashwe njya gufungirwa kubiro by Umurenge ngo kuko umuhuin gu wanjye HABAMENSHI ejo yavuye kwishuri ashonje nuko ajya munsi yurugo guca ikigori cyo kotsa kugirango hanyuma abone ugusubira kwishuri adakerewe. Ntibyatinze umukuru wumurenge yohereje aba local defense kumfata ngo umuhungu wanjyte yaciye ikigori cyo kotsa mumurima wanjye. Naratangaye kuko uretse nokumfata naciwe amande barangije baranankubita bikomeye ngo sinkwiriye kurya ibigori byo mumulima wanjye ngo kugeza leta ya FPR itanze itegeko ryemerera abaturage bose bihingiye ibigori ko bacamo ibigori bitanu byo kotsa kugirango bumve uko ikigori cyokeje kimeze hanyuma ibisigaye bagomba kubigurisha muruganda rukora amavuta ya FPR kugiciro FPR iduhaye. Yenda abantu bataba mu Rwanda bashobora kugirango ndimo kubabeshyera. Urugero rwiza nuko mwareba kwiyi barwa yitangazo rimanitse kubiro byakarre ka RUSIZI no kubiro bikuru by'Umurenge wa MUGANZA. Turatabariza abantu bose aho baba baashobora kubona uburenganzira bwo kuvuga kugirango badufashe kumenyesha amahanga yose ko abaturarwanda bishwe ninzara kubera guhingira ubutegetsi bwa FPR